Pecan Penny’s Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Pecan Penny’s, a vibrant cocktail bar located in the heart of Columbus, Ohio. Known for its lively atmosphere and delectable American cuisine, Pecan Penny’s offers a diverse menu that caters to both casual diners and adventurous foodies.
- Starters: Begin your culinary journey with their BYO BBQ Bowls or the flavorful Mount Nachos, perfect for sharing or savoring solo.
- Salads: Fresh options like the Pennys Salad feature house-smoked beets and candied pecans, making them a must-try.
- Brisket Burgers: The Smokehouse Burger stands out, offering a delicious blend of bacon and G-Daddy aioli, showcasing their commitment to bold flavors.
Whether you're enjoying a relaxing dinner or sipping cocktails during Happy Hour, the welcoming vibe, delicious food, and signature drinks at Pecan Penny's create an unforgettable experience!
Starters
BYO BBQ Bowls
Mount Nachos
House-made tortilla chips topped with queso, jalapeos & Pico de Gallo
Chili
A bowl of our spicy house brisket chili, topped with cheddar, sour cream, jalapeos & scallions. Served with warm cornbread.
Soft Pretzel Sticks
(3) Bavarian Brothers soft pretzel sticks with butter and salt. Served with queso for dipping.
Chips & Dip
House fried tortilla chips, served with queso & Pico de Gallo.
Kool-Aid Pickle
Smoked Pecans
A savory snack of house smoked & seasoned pecans.
Pennys Salad
Mixed Greens, house-smoked beets, candied pecans, tomato, blue cheese, cornbread croutons & cilantro vinaigrette.
Wedge Salad
Iceberg wedge, bacon, diced tomatoes, jalapenos & blue cheese dressing.
House Salad
Mixed greens, cheddar, tomato, red onion & ranch dressing.
Salads
Brisket Burgers
Costanza
BBQ Brisket, cheddar, onion rings & mayo.
Smokehouse Burger
Bacon, cheddar onion rings & G-Daddy aioli.
Veggie Burger
Grilled Impossible burger topped with blue cheese, lettuce, tomato & onions.
Cheeseburger
American cheese, meat and bun.
Brisket
Pulled Pork
Smoked Chicken
St. Louis Ribs
Wings
Downtown Sampler
1/4 Beef Brisket, 1/4 Chicken, 1/4 Pulled Pork, Texas Toast & 2 Sides
Family Meal
1/2 Pulled Pork (8oz) , 1/2 Chicken (8oz), 3 Sides, 4 Pickles & Option of 4 Texas Toast or Buns
Meats
Sandwiches
Smoked Chicken Sandy
Shredded Chicken, Bacon, Provolone & Mozzarella with Jalapeo Aioli on a Potato Bun
Chicago Beef
Chopped Brisket, Giardiniera, Provolone & Mozzarella on a toasted hoagie, with a side of Au Jus.
Grilled Pineapple Pork Sandy
Pulled Pork topped with Cilantro, Grilled Pineappples & G-Daddy sauce on a Potato Bun.
Pork It
Pulled Pork, G-Daddy sauce, slaw & Blue Cheese on a Potato Bun.
Brisket Philly
Chopped Brisket, Grilled Peppers, Onions, Provolone & Mozzarella on a toasted hoagie.
Fried Foghorn
House breaded and fried chicken tenders with white BBQ sauce & Giardiniera on a Potato Bun
KBs Dog
Sauerkraut, Shredded Cheddar, Diced White Onion & Cleveland Stadium Mustard.
Chi-Town Dog
Fresh Tomatoes, Diced white onion, Sports peppers, yellow mustard, relish & a kool-aid pickle.
Double Down Dog
Topped with BBQ brisket, onion rings, ranch & shredded cheddar.
The Whitaker
Brisket chili, shredded cheddar, diced onions, jalapeos & Sour Cream.
OlFaithful
Bun and Dog
Ghost Dog
Cheddar Cheese, Onion Rings, Gochujang Ranch & Giardiniera
Hot Dogs
Sides
Baked Beans
Cheesy Grits
Coleslaw
Collard Greens
* contains pork *
Cornbread
with maple pecan butter
Green Beans
Hush Puppies
with smoked onion remoulade
Mac & Cheese
Mashed Potatoes
Onion Rings
with gochujang ranch
Waffle Fries
Dressing & Sauces
Extra Tortilla Chips
Texas Toast
Bun
Banana Pudding
with vanilla wafers and whipped cream
Funnel Cake Fries
with powdered sugar & Ohio hot pepper jelly